top of page
Search

The hidden losses behind major financial decisions

10 minutes ago
7 min read

This article continues our series exploring how financial advisers can help older clients navigate change, loss and difficult life decisions.


At 76, Margaret understood why her children thought she should sell the family home. It was expensive to maintain, several rooms were rarely used and moving somewhere smaller would make financial sense. For her, the decision was anything but straightforward.

Her husband of 43 years had recently passed away. The home they had shared was filled with memories of their life together. The garden he had lovingly maintained, the kitchen where the family gathered every Christmas and the neighbours who had become lifelong friends.


Selling the house would mean much more than changing her address. It would mean letting go of another important part of the life she had shared with her husband.


In our recent article, Supporting older clients through change and loss, we explored how later-life changes can involve significant emotional losses, even when the practical need for change seems obvious.


Margaret's story* illustrates how these losses can influence financial decisions, and what advisers can do to help.


*Margaret's story is a fictional scenario illustrating challenges that financial advisers may encounter.


When moving makes sense, but staying matters


Margaret was financially comfortable in retirement. However, maintaining her three-bedroom home was becoming increasingly costly and physically demanding. Her adult children were concerned about her living alone and encouraged her to consider downsizing to a smaller, more manageable property, serviced apartments or a retirement village.


From a financial planning perspective, the benefits were clear. Downsizing could reduce household expenses, release additional capital and potentially provide greater suitability and flexibility for future care or support needs.


Yet whenever the subject was raised, Margaret hesitated. She understood the financial arguments but wasn't ready to commit.


Her financial adviser, who had known Margaret and her husband for many years, recognised that the decision involved more than affordability. Rather than immediately revisiting the numbers, the adviser asked what concerned her most about moving.

Margaret spoke about her husband, the garden they had created together and the familiarity and friendships that made the house feel like home. What had appeared to be reluctance to consider a sensible financial decision was, in part, a fear of losing more of the life she had known.


The adviser helped Margaret explore three realistic options: remaining in the home with additional maintenance support, making some practical improvements to reduce its upkeep, or downsizing to a suitable property in the same area.


Together, they considered the financial implications, including the costs of staying, the potential benefits of moving and the longer-term consequences for her retirement finances. Importantly, the adviser also established that Margaret could afford to remain in her home for the foreseeable future, although doing so would involve some additional costs.


Margaret ultimately decided to stay, arrange help with maintenance and review her living arrangements again in another year. It wasn't necessarily the most financially efficient option. However, it was affordable, reflected her priorities and was a decision she could make with confidence.


Her adviser hadn't resolved her grief or persuaded her that downsizing was the right answer. Instead, they had helped her understand her choices and retain control over an important decision. They gave her time to process her options with a clear


Managing change vs. navigating loss


As we discussed in our previous article, there is an important distinction between a change event and the emotional transition that accompanies it.


A change event might involve selling a home, retiring from work, giving up driving or moving into supported accommodation. Each can require practical planning, financial decisions and considerable organisation.


The emotional transition is different. It involves adjusting to what the change means personally, including the things someone may feel they are losing.


For Margaret, selling her home was a practical financial decision. Emotionally, it represented the potential loss of familiar surroundings, cherished memories, independence and a connection to her late husband. What appears to be hesitation, resistance or indecision may reflect concerns that haven't yet been understood or acknowledged.


Of course, not every decision can be delayed, and financial realities cannot be ignored. However, recognising the personal meaning behind a decision can help advisers approach the conversation more effectively.


Six practical ways advisers can help


Financial advisers are often among the trusted professionals who maintain long-term relationships with older clients. These relationships can put them in a valuable position to recognise when major life changes are affecting financial confidence and decision-making.


The challenge is knowing how to respond constructively while remaining within appropriate professional boundaries.


1. Listen to understand what really matters


Before moving into problem-solving mode, take time to understand what the client is experiencing and what concerns them most.


Sometimes the most useful questions are also the simplest:

  • "What concerns you most about this change?"

  • "What would you most like to preserve?"

  • "What would help you feel more comfortable making this decision?"


These questions can reveal important priorities that might otherwise be overlooked.

For Margaret, preserving her connection to her home and community mattered as much as reducing costs. Understanding this helped her adviser explore alternatives that better reflected her goals.


The objective is not to counsel clients through their grief, but to understand the personal circumstances and values influencing their financial decisions.


2. Help clients retain a sense of control


Significant life changes can leave people feeling that decisions are being made for them rather than by them. This is particularly relevant when family members become involved, sometimes with the best of intentions.


Where clients have the capacity and authority to make their own decisions, advisers should ensure their preferences remain central. Family involvement can be helpful, but should be guided by the client's wishes, appropriate consent and relevant legal arrangements. Even when circumstances limit the available options, there may still be meaningful choices about timing, priorities and how decisions are implemented.


Helping clients recognise what remains within their control can support both confidence and independence.


3. Recognise when more time may be needed


Following a major loss, clients may feel overwhelmed by decisions that would previously have seemed manageable. Advisers can help by distinguishing between matters requiring immediate attention and those that can reasonably wait.


For example, after losing a partner, there may be important administrative, estate and financial matters to address promptly. However, decisions about selling a family home or substantially restructuring investments may allow more time.


Where financially and practically appropriate, creating space for consideration can help avoid unnecessary pressure. In Margaret's case, knowing she could afford to remain in her home gave her the freedom to make a considered decision rather than feeling compelled to act immediately. Of course, delaying a decision may also carry costs or risks. These should be explained clearly so that the client can make an informed choice.


4. Make complex decisions easier to understand


Clients facing difficult circumstances may benefit from having financial decisions broken into smaller, more manageable steps. Clear explanations, simple comparisons, written summaries and scenario planning can help clients understand their choices and the implications of each.


Advisers should also adapt their communication to individual needs and preferences, allowing time for questions and checking understanding rather than assuming that providing information is enough. For example, comparing the longer-term financial outcomes of remaining in a home versus downsizing can make an otherwise daunting decision feel more manageable.


The aim is to help clients make informed decisions, not simply to persuade them that a recommended option is financially optimal.


5. Recognise vulnerability without making assumptions


Grief, illness and major life changes can sometimes affect a person's confidence, concentration or ability to manage complex decisions. However, experiencing distress does not automatically mean someone lacks decision-making capacity, and age alone should never be treated as evidence of incapacity.


Advisers should remain alert to signs that clients may be struggling to understand information, are experiencing undue pressure or may be at risk of financial exploitation. Where concerns arise, appropriate professional, legal or organisational safeguards should be followed.


Particular care may be needed when family members are involved in decisions about significant assets, access to money or changes to financial arrangements.


Protecting clients' interests includes respecting their independence while recognising situations where additional safeguards or specialist assistance may be appropriate.


6. Know when additional support is needed


There is an important distinction between recognising a client's emotional difficulties and taking responsibility for resolving them. Financial advisers are not psychologists, grief counsellors or medical professionals. Their role is to listen, understand relevant personal circumstances, explain financial implications and provide appropriate advice.


Where clients are experiencing significant or prolonged distress, advisers may encourage them to seek assistance from a GP, psychologist, grief counsellor or other qualified professional. Similarly, complex legal, care or family disputes may require specialist advice beyond the financial adviser's expertise.


The goal is not to become responsible for every aspect of a client's wellbeing. It is to recognise when additional support could help and to work within the boundaries of a trusted professional relationship.


Supporting ‘best’ decisions


Margaret's experience highlights an important lesson. Financial planning is ultimately about helping people make decisions that support their goals, needs, priorities and best interests. These are shaped not only by financial circumstances but also by relationships, identity, independence and the things that give life meaning.


This doesn't mean avoiding difficult conversations or overlooking financial realities. Nor does it mean advisers should take responsibility for helping clients overcome grief or come to terms with every loss.


It means recognising that significant financial decisions are often connected to much bigger life changes. Financial advisers cannot prevent many of the losses that accompany later life or remove the grief, uncertainty and frustration those losses may bring.


They can help clients understand their options, make their best decisions at an appropriate pace and retain a sense of ownership over the choices affecting their future. Helping them navigate change and loss with greater clarity, confidence and a sense of control.


For advisers who build long-term client relationships, that can be one of the most meaningful ways to demonstrate the value of good financial advice.


References


Authors

In this ongoing series of blogs, we will further unpack our practical ideas and tips to help all Australians achieve a dignified retirement.



Humphrey Armstrong is a retired psychologist and consultant to MYMAVINS with decades of experience helping Australians navigate their transition to retirement and journey successfully through their third act.











Tai Rotem is consulting director at MYMAVINS with several decades experience in financial consumer, public health, social and behavioural change research.


Reach out to him at Tai@mymavins.com.au


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page